Playing fields at DeFazio Park/ Credit: Needham Observer

The School Committee has reached out to the Park and Recreation Commission in hopes of engaging in a “collaborative process” that might persuade Park & Rec to rethink its opposition to siting a new middle school at the DeFazio Park complex off Dedham Avenue.

“Our shared goal is to work together to meet the community’s critical need for a new middle school facility while ensuring that Needham’s educational and recreational priorities are both protected and enhanced for generations to come,” School Committee Chair Michael O’Brien wrote in an Oct. 24 letter to Park & Rec Chair Chris Gerstel.

O’Brien proposed “a joint meeting of our boards at the earliest opportunity for this essential dialogue and planning process.”

Gerstel told the Observer that he and his colleagues are willing to meet with the School Committee, but he said it is not likely to result in a change of position.

“There’s just too many uncertainties,” Gerstel said.

O’Brien said, “For the School Committee, DeFazio is still on the table. But we want all town boards to feel comfortable with the option that’s ultimately put forward.”

The work done on the project to date has indicated there are advantages to the DeFazio site and challenges at the alternative side at the rear of the Pollard property that merit keeping DeFazio under consideration. 

For Park & Rec, DeFazio’s seeming advantages are offset by the impacts construction would have on its seven current playing fields and its tot lot, impacts that would be felt for three years or perhaps longer. 

Representatives of HMFH, the project’s design firm, and members of the School Building Committee offered a detailed presentation on those impacts and how they might be mitigated at Park & Rec’s Oct. 22 meeting. 

Matt LaRue from HMFH said if construction were to occur at DeFazio, the first DeFazio elements to be affected would be Healy Field, a multipurpose grass field that would be taken out of commission to support construction, and the current parking lot. The project would also eventually require the Asa Small Little League baseball diamond, the tot lot and the pavilion at DeFazio.

Parking would be relocated, and it would offer around 160 spots, fewer than the current estimated 200 spots.

The construction area would be totally fenced off and activities could continue at the other DeFazio fields. 

Eventually — after the new school is constructed and the old Pollard demolished — the lost fields and the tot lot would be replaced by new fields and a tot lot at the Pollard site. There would be significantly more parking and an upgraded parking area at DeFazio, one that could be paved and less plagued by potholes and puddles thanks to stormwater detention practices at the new school.

“So in the end, the same number of fields would exist as you have today. You would get three fields newly built on the Pollard site,” LaRue said. “Yes, they are no longer all together on one site. And that’s a big change, I realize that.

“But I think there’s some sense that these new fields on the Pollard site could help disperse some of the intensity and traffic so it’s not all borne by the parking lot at DeFazio.”

Park & Rec commissioners expressed grave concerns about having operations disrupted for multiple years. They said its many user groups would suffer and that they were receiving no guarantees that the funds for refurbishing or reconstruction of fields would be included in the overall project budget.

After the meeting, the commissioners submitted a list of 28 questions and concerns that included a request for a timeline for field redevelopment, the estimated costs for rehab and reconstruction and how it would be paid for, how parking and traffic circulation would be handled during the construction process and how the construction would affect the overall DeFazio infrastructure, such as its irrigation system and storage areas utilized by its user groups.

They were told that Healy Field would be impacted for 45 months, Asa Small for 41 months, and the pavilion area for 30 months. 

Gerstel said he appreciated  the information but doubted the commission would change its stance and relinquish its jurisdiction.

“I was extremely impressed with the presentation that they made. They’re not sugar coating it, but that is way longer than we’d anticipated,” he said of the duration of the disruptions.

He emphasized the lack of any commitment that project funds would go to refurbishing and/or relocating the fields. “Speaking as one commissioner, nothing has swayed our vote to go in a different direction.

“And I can say this bluntly: It’s actually pushed me even further to what our original two decisions were.”

 Save as PDF

Click here to go Home