At this Newbury Park site, a stand of large trees like the ones behind the neighboring house has been clearcut for new construction. Credit: Needham Observer

Approximately one quarter of this fall’s 24-page Town Meeting warrant is the text of a proposed bylaw that attempts to slow down Needham’s rate of deforestation. The Needham Tree Preservation Planning Committee has been paring and pruning this legislation since March 2025, and it has been the subject of four public hearings. Its fate will be a major topic of discussion at Special Town Meeting Oct. 19. 

The proposal has already garnered the backing of both the Finance Committee and the Select Board, although neither vote was unanimous. 

Gabby Queenan, the town’s sustainability manager, began her presentation to the Finance Committee Sept. 30 by describing what the bylaw doesn’t attempt to do. “It is not a general prohibition on cutting trees,” she said.

Queenan said that there are 75-80 teardowns a year in Needham. The clear cutting that often accompanies these projects is the main target of this bylaw.

The bylaw would impose costs on a property owner who cuts down mature trees in the unbuildable setbacks at the lot’s perimeter. Those costs could be avoided by replanting or retaining other trees. The law only comes into play when a project requires permitting from the building department. Ït does not apply to trees in the buildable area of a lot or with trees that are diseased or dangerous. 

“What we’re trying to address is not someone cutting down a tree to put in a swing set or get more light on their patio,” said committee chair and Select Board Chair Heidi Frail. “It’s the substantial loss of mature tree canopy that can accompany major redevelopment.”

Property owners who decide to cut down a protected tree have two options: They can replant elsewhere on the property or pay a fine to the town that will be used for tree planting and preservation. The fee is based on each tree’s diameter at breast level (DBH), and only applies to trees with a diameter of greater than 6 inches. The fee is set at $300 per inch of DBH above 6 inches and is slightly lower than most neighboring communities. 

“We hope we won’t be generating revenue,” said Frail. “We hope to be preserving trees.”

Property owners who decide to build Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) are exempt from the bylaw, and property owners who have less than 80 feet of frontage can ask the town’s tree warden to be exempted. 

There is a 12-month look-back period when a construction permit is pulled, aimed at preventing the cutting of protected trees in the lead up to a major project. 

The Tree Preservation planning committee included representatives from the Planning Board, the Climate Action Committee, the Stormwater Working Group, the Conservation Commission, the Large House Review Study Committee, the Select Board, two developers and a certified master gardener. It is the town’s third effort at tree regulation. The 2016 and 2021 committees failed to bear fruit.

This proposal includes one provision that was not in the tree ordinances in 17 other cities and towns that the committee reviewed. It credits each overstory tree that is retained or planted anywhere on the property. An overstory tree is one that is over 40 feet in height or as a planting, one that will attain 40 feet of height in its lifespan. The credits, which encourage planting larger trees as opposed to small, ornamental ones, would allow the cutting of other trees in the protected area at a ratio of double or triple DBH.

Queenan cited the Charles River Watershed’s GIS study that estimates that Needham is losing an amount of tree canopy equivalent to the area of 14 football fields annually. 

In the four public forums, most speakers thought that the bylaw did not go far enough to protect trees.

In the last public forum at the Select Board on Sept. 8, several speakers questioned a provision that exempted town building projects from this bylaw. Steve Maxwell was one of two no votes at the Finance Committee. “I fully support the intent of the bylaw, but I have a philosophical problem with placing a burden on an individual homeowner that I won’t also place on the town itself.”

Frail defended the town’s exemption at both the Finance Committee meeting and at the Select Board. “Every municipal project includes landscaping, and every municipal project plants more than we remove,” she said. “Also, the town is governed under multiple general laws about the treatment of trees.”

Speakers at the Select Board’s public hearing questioned whether the Pollard project would be subject to this bylaw. Hank Haff, the town’s director of design and construction, assessed the potential impact of the bylaw if applied to Pollard construction plans. He reported to the Permanent Building Committee Sept. 14 that there were many overstory trees on the property edges that would remain untouched. In a theoretical application of the bylaw, those trees would provide offsets to allow the cutting of trees within the footprint of the new school without incurring fines. In addition, the plans include the planting of new trees.

Josh Levy, Select Board member and a representative from the Stormwater Working Group to the Tree Preservation Planning Committee, voted for the bylaw but said that the town exemption should be eliminated. “The fact that we generally comply or do more than what would be required makes it an easy choice for me” he said. “The optics of just exempting the town doesn’t look good.”

Frail pointed out that there could be projects, such as roadway work, where there is no opportunity for remedial tree planting. Eliminating the exemption would raise construction costs. “I see no benefit in the town paying itself given that the town is going above and beyond, in my estimation, of planting trees.”

She cited the program that plants and maintains a free tree in Needham front lawns at the request of the homeowner as an example of the town’s efforts to maintain tree cover.

Bill Dermody was the sole no vote on the Select Board. He said, “I’ve heard from some constituents who are very concerned about the way it’s written, the obligations for two years afterwards.” 

Dermody was referring to a provision in the bylaw that allows the town to monitor any trees planted or used as offset credits for two years after construction. 

He told the Observer that he’s heard many other concerns from constituents including that a tree in the setback could have a critical root zone that extends 30 feet into the buildable area, making construction very difficult in smaller lots. 

“There needs to be a tree bylaw; I just don’t love it in its current form,” he said. He  prefers examining it more carefully and waiting until May 2027 to present it to regular Town Meeting..  

A majority of Select Board members voted against postponing Town Meeting’s consideration of this bylaw. 

“I feel a sense of urgency,” said Select Board member Cathy Dowd. “Trees are being cut down all the time.”

“Everyone wants something to protect the trees,” added Select Board member Kevin Keane, “People are desperate for this. They’re heartsick when they see lots clearcut.”

In only 16 months, lightning speed for Needham’s boards, the Tree Preservation Planning Committee has crafted a proposal for Town Meeting’s final approval. If it passes, Needham may throw a little more shade.

 Save as PDF

Click here to go Home